ARTIST: Stuart Brisley born 1933
MEDIUM: 23 photographs, black and white, on paper on card
DIMENSIONS: Image: 425 x 546 mm
COLLECTION: Tate
ACQUISITION: Purchased 1981
REFERENCE: T03315

Although not intended to depict anything to do with thoughts are the human mind directly in the way I’m exhibiting it, I instantly related to this art piece. The photo was taken to portray sympathy with miners, however my interpretation is that it also can symbolise the feeling of being held back other down because of yourself. The threads holing the artist down to the ground are fragile in the relation to the man, they could be easily broken by him but instead he let’s them weigh him down and hinder him from being truly creative. In the same way, our feelings or mentality can weigh us down to hinder is from truly expressing ourselves, even though these obstacles can be easier to break than we think. The threads can metaphorically be these heavy thoughts that may seem easily broken by an observer, the subject himself can however not see the possibility to break them.


“‘Beneath Dignity, Bregenz’ (1977) was performed in conjunction with an exhibition of British art in Austria (Englishe Kunst der Gegenwart in September 1971); Brisley was invited by Norbert Lynton to take part. Brisley had worked during this year on an Artist Placement Group project in Peterlee in a community of miners and the title is indicative of his sympathy with the miners, and the lowness (and implied loneliness) of their working conditions. The work that preceded it had a similar preoccupation with digging and working in appalling conditions.

In Bregenz he was presented with a strikingly different environment: a picturesque town by the side of a lake (Lake Constance) with a small mountain behind. This work is a response to this setting, the movement from mountain to flat ground and the lake (from the vertical to the horizontal). He chose to work on a quayside, using five roughly constructed frames which marked the limits of his physical reach. The materials which he employed were water, chalk, powder (flour) and paint (black and white). He made five separate statements using each of the materials, working in all for four days. In order to reduce the drama of the work (a character that Brisley abhors) the fifth frame was a mixture of black and white. On the last day the audience was large and Brisley avoided a climax to the work by jumping into the lake and swimming, replicating his drawing action in water, another medium. He describes his action here as similar to the other works in the Tate’s collection, showing a preoccupation with formal, sculptural problems. It is possible however that Brisley may, in hindsight, be emphasising this aspect at the expense of his political concerns.

The photographer for this work was his friend Janet Anderson; he preferred her photographsto those of a trained photographer, who he felt would have a particular and exclusive aesthetic. The viewpoint for these photographs was fixed and decided upon by discussion between Brisley and the photographer.” (tate.org.uk)